Pointing the finger at Roy Hodgson for England’s failure to beat Slovakia could be a big mistake, according to a leading psychologist.

As we are seeing all too vividly at Euro 2016 when a team loses – or even draws – the manager is usually the first person to carry the can.

But Nick Chater, professor of behavioural science at Warwick Business School,
says blaming, or sacking, him is often the result of a dangerous ‘mental shortcut’.

He calls this phenomenon ‘attribute substitution’ – taking the easiest option

Speaking on BBC Radio 4’s The Human Zoo, he revealed this is where we substitute a hard question for a much easier one.

England now face a potential quarter final with hosts France, if they get past Iceland on Monday.

But Prof Chater said instead of answering ‘how good is the manager?’ – which is very hard because there are so many factors that lead to a team’s success or failure – people instead ask ‘do we like the manager?’

Or ‘do they look competent?’ Or, even more simply, ‘did their team win?’

He said: “This is attribute substitution. Instead of trying to solve a hard problem we solve an easier one instead. We do it all the time.

“When people are asked to judge if one city is bigger than another, people often give an answer to which city is the more famous.

“Climate change is another example.

“Instead of examining the scientific evidence, which is of course pretty complex, we may instead substitute the questions ‘which newspaper do I trust?’

“Or even ‘is it unusually warm today?’

“Indeed, studies have shown people are more likely to believe long term climate change is real during an unusually warm spell of weather.

“When we are asked a question we are not confident we can answer, it is very natural to find a related question we can answer, and very often that is an easier question we can answer.”

Experiments have also suggested we may use physical appearance to make decisions.

One experiment asked Swiss school children who they wanted as captain of their ship based on faces of French election candidates, who they had never seen before, and found they tended to pick those who were elected.

When managers take a risk and get away with it they are often lauded, despite their decisions being illogical at the time – the easy question ‘did it work out okay in this particular game?’ tends to be substituted for the harder question ‘how competent is this manager?’

Jerker Denrell, also a professor of behavioural science at Warwick Business School, says people often mistake skill for luck or chance.

He explained: “Skill matters enormously in some areas, but people generalise it.

“For instance I will never beat Usain Bolt at 100m, he has a high level of skill that is reproducible.

“But that is not the case in other settings.

“Take trading. Even when you know nothing you can still achieve fantastic results by picking randomly, just by luck you can beat the best traders.

“When we looked at stock forecasters, people will evaluate the most exceptional forecaster as the most accurate in their predictions, and people see that as a sign of skill.

“But we found the most accurate forecaster is not necessarily a good forecaster as one way to become very accurate is to make outrageous forecasts, which are not repeatable.

“It increases your chances of being the most accurate – to go against the grain and bet big – but these people on the cover of the Wall Street Journal, the most exceptional forecasters, should not be followed as they will not be able to repeat it.

“This is applies to the fastest growing companies as well, as many have since gone bankrupt.

“Our study in Sweden found that exceptionally high growth is in fact a predictor of lower than average growth in the future.”


    • Associate news editor John kicked off his career in journalism when he was with news agency SWNS in its’ earliest days over 30 years ago. During this time he’s had the honor of working with some major newspaper titles including the Daily Express and The Sun, both as district and head office reporters.

    • Show Comments (0)

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    comment *

    • name *

    • email *

    • website *


    You May Also Like



    A mum with a rare set of chromosomes has issued a heartbreaking plea for ...

    A cat charity has come up with an unusual new way for people to interact with the animals in its care - by installing a live webcam feed. Thanks to two new webcams, people will be able to go to the Cats Protection website and follow the antics of whichever cat is currently staying in one pen at the National Cat Adoption Centre. The pinhole cameras have been installed in the top and side of the pen at the charity's centre in Chelwood Gate, East Sussex. They will be on every day when staff on duty between 8.15 am and 4.45 pm so viewers can watch the mogs eat, play and sleep. Cats Protection's virtual homing manager Clare Kiernan said the charity hopes that by giving cat lovers an insight into the daily life of some of its cats, more people will choose to adopt through its branches or adoption centres. She said: "We're always looking for ways to tell people about the many wonderful cats we have in our care throughout the UK that need a new, loving home. "The webcams seemed like a brilliant idea to us, so people can see for themselves just how funny, charming and entertaining cats can be. "Whether you're taking a sneaky break from work to log on, or watching online with the kids, the live stream is endlessly entertaining. "From the high-energy mayhem created when the pen is occupied by a litter of kittens, to the calming and relaxing vibes from a resting older cat, we hope that by tuning in viewers will get a sense of what they're missing out on." Cats Protection is thought to be the first UK cat charity to install cameras in one of its centres. The idea is not completely new, though, as The Donkey Sanctuary in Devon and Edinburgh Zoo in Scotland also have similar cameras installed. Clare, who joined the charity last July, said the cameras will always be in the same pen but the cats people get to see will change as they find new homes. She also said the home plans to put in more cameras in the coming months. She said: "The cat on show will probably change every week or so as the cats go to their forever homes. "We hope to have some kittens in there soon - we did when we were trying this out and it was very entertaining. "We hope to scale it up and put cameras in other branches of the charity. "Some of them are quite remote so it would hopefully highlight the cats there more." All camera-ready cats are ready to go to a new home and first in the hot-seat is two-year-old Eric. He has been at the home for just under two weeks. Clare said: "We picked him to be first because he is a very affectionate cat. "His previous owners said he acts like a dog because of the way he follows people around. I don't think he will be here long."


    West Highland terriers, followed by Labradors are the dog breeds most likely to get ...



    Having constant alerts on your smartphone increase inattention and hyperactivity, a new study warned. ...