Gary McGaghey on Why Finance Leadership Is Becoming More Human, Not Less

Gary McGaghey on Why Finance Leadership Is Becoming More Human, Not Less

In recent years, the role of the CFO has become increasingly associated with data, systems and automation. Finance leaders are expected to provide faster insight, strengthen controls, improve forecasting and help businesses make better decisions in more complex operating environments. At the same time, technology is changing the way finance functions work, with artificial intelligence and automation beginning to reshape everything from reporting to planning.

Yet for Gary McGaghey, the future of finance leadership is not becoming less human. If anything, it is becoming more so. As businesses become larger, more international and more reliant on data, the need for trust, judgement and emotional intelligence becomes even more important. The modern CFO still needs technical rigour and commercial discipline, but they also need the ability to lead people through uncertainty, build confidence across teams and ensure that transformation is properly understood across the organisation.

McGaghey has built his career across a range of sectors, ownership structures and geographies. His experience includes senior finance and executive roles in FMCG, beverages, pharmaceuticals, digital marketing services and facilities management, with a background spanning listed, privately owned and private equity backed businesses. He has worked across Africa, the UK, Europe, the Middle East, Asia Pacific and the US, giving him a broad perspective on how global businesses operate and how teams respond to change.

That experience has shaped a clear view of the CFO role. Finance cannot operate as a separate technical function, disconnected from the commercial and operational realities of the business. It has to be close enough to understand what is happening on the ground, disciplined enough to provide challenge, and trusted enough that colleagues see it as a partner rather than a barrier.

This is particularly important in international businesses, where transformation rarely happens in a neat or linear way. Different markets may have different systems, working practices, customer expectations and levels of operational maturity. A central finance model may provide useful structure, but it cannot simply be imposed without regard for local context. The challenge is to create consistency where it adds value, while still respecting the expertise and judgement of teams closest to customers and operations.

For McGaghey, that balance depends heavily on leadership style. Technical authority can establish credibility, but it does not automatically create commitment. Teams are more likely to engage with change when they understand the reason for it, trust the people leading it and can see how it helps the business work better. In that sense, emotional intelligence is not a soft alternative to financial discipline. It is part of how discipline is delivered effectively.

This matters because finance teams often sit at the intersection of ambition and reality. They are expected to support growth, but also to manage risk. They must help the business move quickly, but not carelessly. They need to challenge plans, but without becoming obstructive. That requires judgement, communication and the ability to ask difficult questions in a way that improves decision-making rather than creating defensiveness.

McGaghey’s approach has been shaped by extensive experience in M&A, carve-outs, integrations, refinancing and global transformation. Across these environments, he has seen that the technical plan is only one part of successful execution. A transaction or integration may have a strong strategic rationale, but value is only realised when people across the business understand what needs to change and are supported in delivering it.

This is especially true in private equity backed environments, where pace and performance discipline are often heightened. Private equity ownership can create a clear focus on value creation, investment in capability and more urgent transformation agendas. But sustainable value is rarely created by short-term activity alone. It depends on building stronger teams, better systems, and more reliable data. Those foundations allow businesses to grow with greater confidence and resilience.

In his current role as Group CFO of a leading private equity owned international facilities management company, McGaghey is operating in a sector where these themes are especially relevant. Facilities management is a service led industry, and service led businesses depend on people. Customers expect reliability, consistency and responsiveness, often across complex and high pressure environments. Systems, processes and financial insight all matter, but they ultimately need to support the people delivering services every day.

That is why finance transformation in this kind of business cannot be treated as a back office exercise. Better reporting, stronger data and more scalable systems may appear internal, but their value is practical. They help leaders understand performance more clearly, support operational teams more effectively and make more confident decisions. Over time, that can improve the customer experience by enabling greater consistency, clearer accountability and better visibility across the business.

McGaghey is also careful to emphasise that transformation at scale is always a collective effort. A CFO may help provide financial discipline, structure and insight, but progress depends on the quality of the wider leadership team and the people working across the business. Regional leaders, operational teams, functional specialists and finance colleagues all play a role in making change work. The strength of the organisation lies in how effectively those groups collaborate around a shared direction.

This collaborative mindset is particularly important when businesses are integrating acquisitions or aligning different operating models. Integration is often discussed in terms of synergies, systems and structure, but it is just as much about people and trust. Teams need to understand what is changing, what is staying the same and how the business will support them through the transition. If that is not handled carefully, even well-designed transformation programmes can lose momentum.

Data is another area where McGaghey takes a practical view. The growing interest in artificial intelligence is understandable, and AI has the potential to improve decision-making, productivity and insight across many sectors. But AI depends on the quality of the data behind it. Businesses that want to make effective use of AI need to first build a solid foundation of  integrated metrics, and robust data governance. Without those foundations, AI risks becoming an expensive distraction rather than a meaningful source of value.

This is not a cautious view of technology, but a disciplined one. In large international businesses, fragmented data can limit visibility and slow decision-making. Stronger data foundations give leaders a clearer view of performance, help identify patterns and make it easier to allocate resources where they are needed. Once those foundations are in place, AI and advanced analytics can support further efficiencies and growth opportunities.

The same principle applies more broadly to the CFO role. The best finance leaders do not simply produce information. They help the business understand what the information means. They provide clarity where there is complexity, challenge where there is overconfidence and reassurance where there is uncertainty. They help the organisation make decisions that are commercially ambitious but properly grounded.

For McGaghey, this is where the human element of finance leadership becomes most important. Numbers are essential, but numbers do not interpret themselves. Data can point to a trend, but judgement is needed to understand its significance. A forecast can show a risk, but leadership is needed to decide how to respond. A system can create efficiency, but people still need to trust it, use it and understand its purpose.

As businesses continue to invest in automation and AI, finance functions will undoubtedly become more data led. Routine reporting may become faster. Analysis may become more sophisticated. Forecasting may become more dynamic. But the CFO’s ability to build trust, develop teams and lead through complexity will remain central to performance.

McGaghey’s career reflects that balance. He brings technical finance experience, international perspective and a background in complex transformation, but his approach places equal weight on people, culture and communication. In modern finance leadership, those qualities are not secondary. They are increasingly fundamental.

The CFO of the future will need to be commercially sharp, technologically aware and comfortable operating in fast-moving environments. But they will also need to be human: able to listen, build confidence, support teams and lead change in a way that people can understand. For Gary McGaghey, that is not a departure from financial leadership. It is what effective financial leadership now requires.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *